Second UN Treaty Body Focused Review Pilot Takes Place in Grenada

From 23 to 24 March 2022, the Geneva Human Rights Platform (GHRP) conducted in Grenada,  in collaboration with the Commonwealth Secretariat, its second pilot of a United Nations (UN) treaty bodies (TBs) focused review – designed to discuss how countries implement specific recommendations issued by UN TBs between sessions.

Felix Kirchmeier and Domenico Zipoli travelled to St. George’s to facilitate the pilot focused review on the latest recommendations issued by two UN TBs – the Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) – with national actors, focusing on a limited number of core themes.

They were accompanied by an informal TB delegation composed of one member from each committee – travelling in their personal capacity –, one staff of the Commonwealth Secretariat, and representatives of the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Regional Office for Central America and of the UN Barbados and the Eastern Caribbean Multi-Country Office (MCO).

In-Situ Visits

A full day of in-situ visits – ahead of the actual discussions around the TB recommendations – allowed the TB delegation to visit institutions working on the core themes identified for the pilot: the national machinery for the advancement of women, violence against women, juvenile justice, the harmonization of legislation on child rights, as well as corporal punishment and discrimination.

‘The visits prior to the pilot focus review enabled us to discover three very concrete projects related to children's rights: a school for teenage mothers, a shelter for mothers who are victims of violence and a rehabilitation centre for children in conflict with the law. The exchanges with the stakeholders, and in one case with the children, confronted us with contrasting realities: a lot of goodwill on the part of the stakeholders, but far too few resources to meet the challenges.

These visits fuelled the debate during the dialogue with state actors, and enabled the questions asked to be more targeted and in line with the reality of the country’ says Benoit Van Keirsblick, a member of the UN CRC.

A Multi-Sectoral Participation that Sparked a National Dialogue on Implementation

During a two-day workshop, the TB delegation discussed with national actors– representatives from different ministries, statutory bodies like the Office of the Ombudsman and the Child Protection Authority, and national civil society organizations (CSOs) – how recommendations are implemented on the ground and related challenges.

This in-country interaction facilitated multi-sectoral participation that would have otherwise not happened in Geneva.

According to several participants, this approach was considered much more in-depth and useful than the ‘standard’ preparation for the full TB review, based on desk research, email exchanges and siloed participation by different national human rights actors.

‘This spurred a nation-wide discussion on the implementation of TB recommendations and each stakeholders’ role in the monitoring and reporting to the different committees’ explains Felix Kirchmeier, Executive Director of the Geneva Human Rights Platform.

A session of the focused review pilot in Grenada

‘This exercise was also an opportunity for both the National Coordinating Committee on Human Rights and national CSOs to strengthen their engagement with each other in light of the ongoing review cycles of both the CRC and CEDAW. The commitment to stronger cooperation between government and CSOs represents a clear result of the focused review pilot’ underlines Dr Domenico Zipoli, Project Coordinator at the Geneva Human Rights Platform.

‘The Commonwealth Secretariat has continued to work on providing technical assistance to the Member States in improving their engagement with Geneva-based mechanisms, such as the UPR and treaty bodies. With processes like the focused review that aim to bring the Geneva process closer to reality, the national institutions and states' engagement with UN mechanisms will be strengthened even further’ says Yashasvi Nain, Human Rights Officer, Commonwealth Secretariat.

An Essential Learning Experience

Prior to the pilot focused review, the majority of national participants had not engaged with reporting to the TB system directly. The two-day sessions in St George’s, modelled around the modalities of dialogue taking place during the Geneva-based sessions, provided national human rights actors with a first-hand experience of the state reporting procedure as well as more precise insights into the rights prescribed in the conventions. At the same time, it also facilitated a more practical understanding by the participating TB members of the challenges to implementation specific to the Grenadian context.

‘The exercise was very useful for all parties involved. Those of us who attended from abroad were able to immerse ourselves in the current reality that the country is experiencing with its strengths and limitations. And both state bodies and civil society found a new space to channel their concerns and receive guidance and ongoing support’ says Leticia Bonifaz Alfonzo, a member of the CEDAW.

‘With the goal of promoting and protecting human rights within the Commonwealth, the Secretariat has continued to work with member countries towards strengthening national institutions and mechanisms. In order to strengthen treaty bodies effectively, national mechanisms and national actors also need to effectively engage with them – in-country reviews offer this opportunity’ underlines Dr Shavana Haythornthwaite, Head of the Human Rights Unit at the Commonwealth Secretariat.

What’s Next

The report of this Grenada focused review pilot will be published within the next three weeks and the GHRP staff will brief the CRC and CEDAW about this second focused review pilot during their upcoming sessions in Geneva.

‘With this second pilot, we start having a clearer image of the benefits and format of these focused reviews and we are currently discussing the possibility of conducting further pilots in Europe and the Asia-Pacific throughout 2022. At the end of the process, an overall report will entail the lessons learned and recommendations regarding the format and benefits of these focused reviews.’ says Felix Kirchmeier.

MORE ON THIS THEMATIC AREA

Peru, Fruit processing plant in Chincha, south of Lima. News

Holding States Accountable for Implementing the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights

25 March 2022

Our new Working Paper examines existing mechanisms at the national, regional and international levels for holding states accountable for their performance in implementing the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights.

Read more

Social media icons News

Placing Human Rights at the Centre of Regulatory Frameworks and Legislation on Online Harm

18 January 2022

In light of concerns about the dissemination of illegal content, disinformation and misinformation via online platforms and social media, our new  Working Paper Regulatory Approaches to Online Harms and Human Rights: Three Case Studies discusses how to best place human rights at the centre of regulatory frameworks and legislation on online harms.

Read more

A Girl Looks on Among Afghan Women Lining Up To Receive Relief Assistance, During The Holy Month of Ramadan in Jalalabad, Afghanistan. Event

Rights of Women and Girls in Afghanistan

30 June 2022, 15:00-16:45

This event aims at raising international awareness on the human rights situation of women and girls in Afghanistan and propose
recommendations for effective action by the international community.

Read more

Cover page of the Istanbul Protocol Event

One Step Closer to a World Without Torture: Launch of the Istanbul Protocol 2022

29 June 2022, 14:00-16:00

This event marks the official launch of the updated Istanbul Protocol, with Michelle Bachelet, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, together with representatives of the core UN anti-torture mechanisms and other international human rights bodies.

Read more

Greece, ylakio, pre-removal center. Short Course

Introduction to International Human Rights Law

Fall 2022

This short course, which can be followed in Geneva or online, will provide participants with an introduction to substantive human rights law. It will start with an introduction to the nature and sources of international human rights law and its place in the international legal system. The course will then provide a presentation of the main principles applicable to substantive rights (jurisdiction, obligation and limitations).

Read more

Afghanistan, Parwan detention facility. Inside a room where detainees of the prison, separated by an acrylic glass, are allowed to meet with their families a couple of times per year with the help of the ICRC employees who facilitate the programme. Short Course

Preventing and Combating Terrorism

Spring 2023

This short course, which can be followed in Geneva or online, discusses the extent to which states may limit and/or derogate from their international human rights obligations in order to prevent and counter-terrorism and thus protect persons under their jurisdiction.

Read more

George Floyd protest in Washington D.C. Project

Promoting and Protecting the Rights to Freedom of Peaceful Assembly and Association and Civic Space Worldwide

Started in June 2020

This project aims at providing support to the UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights to Freedom of Peaceful Assembly and of Association Clément Voulé by addressing emerging issues affecting civic space and eveloping tools and materials allowing various stakeholders to promote and defend civic space.

Read more

Session of the UN Human Rights Committee Project

Treaty Body Review 2020 and Beyond

Started in January 2018

The Geneva Human Rights Platform contributes to this review process by providing expert input via different avenues, by facilitating dialogue on the review among various stakeholders, as well as by accompanying the development of a follow-up resolution to 68/268 in New York and in Geneva.

Read more

Cover of the publication Publication

Implementing the Treaty Body Review 2020 – Where do we stand

published on May 2022

Felix Kirchmeier, Chloé Naret, Domenico Zipoli

Read more