Universality in the Human Rights Council

Completed in October 2019

Universality is one of the guiding principles contained in the mandate of the UN Human Rights Council (HRC). The HRC, through its subject matter coverage of the human rights (HR) recognized in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and its role as the host of the Universal Periodic Review as well as a range of other monitoring mechanisms, is an institution that claims to embody and promote both the formal and the substantive aspects of the universality of international HR law.

What are some of the meanings that have been given to HR universality by the HRC and its members and have these changed during the first decade of the institution’s existence? How does universality articulate with other foundational principles, such as equality, respect for cultural diversity, and the indivisibility and interdependence of all HR, which underline the work of the HRC? What challenges and opportunities do discussions around the concept of HR universality within the HRC present for the universal implementation of all HR for all people?

Contemporary Challenges

An examination of the practice of the HRC over the past decade suggests that despite general agreement on the universal nature of most HR guarantees, there are significant differences of opinion surrounding the specific meaning and content that should be given to these rights, the manner in which HR should be weighed against one another, and the ways human rights should be implemented in national and regional contexts. Challenges to universality in the HRC take a variety of forms and these have also changed over time in response to debates occurring in other parts of the UN system and in the broader community at the international, regional and national levels.

The studies note that discussions about the universality of HR in the HRC can play an important part in advancing the universal protection of HR, for example, by developing or strengthening recognition of the equal rights of particular groups, such as indigenous peoples or minorities. Challenges to universality may, however, undermine the protection afforded by universal HR guarantees. In a number of contexts, particularist claims are advanced to the detriment of the HR of women and girls, migrants, and LGBTI persons, or to justify non-compliance with HR in particular situations, such as real or perceived threats of terrorism.

The Project

This project, launched in 2015, examines different concepts of universality, maps contemporary challenges to the principle of HR universality in the context of specific themes covered by the HRC and discusses the role of the HRC in the promotion and protection of universally guaranteed HR.

OUTPUT

Research Brief

The Research Brief Universality in the Human Rights Council: Challenges and Achievements presents in a short format the insights and key messages of a larger, ongoing research project. It outlines the meanings that have been given to universality by the HRC and its members, analyzes whether these have changed during the first decade of the institution’s existence, and discusses how universality articulates with other foundational principles contained in the mandate of the HRC, such as equality, respect for cultural diversity, and the indivisibility and interdependence of all HR. The Research Brief also outlines the challenges and opportunities that discussions around the concept of universality within the HRC present for the universal implementation of all human rights for all people.

Expert Panel: Universality in the Human Rights Council

To commemorate Human Rights Day and the 10th Anniversary of the HRC, panelists at this event explored how the HRC has developed the concept of universality and responded to the contemporary challenges to the universal application of international HR law. Specific examples of the HRC’s discussions in connection with counter terrorism and HR, the right to development and the rights of marginalised groups, including LGBTI persons and migrants, were used to illustrate the ways in which the institution is approaching universality.

MORE ON THIS THEMATIC AREA

A session of a UN treary body in Geneva News

Formal Launch of the 2020 Review of UN Treaty Bodies: Our Input

June 2020

The Geneva Human Rights Platform has been contributing to this review by providing expert input, by facilitating dialogue on the review among various stakeholders, as well as by accompanying the discussions towards the follow-up resolution to 68/268 in New York and in Geneva.

Read more

UN general Assemby News

The Geneva Human Rights Platform Inputs the Final Stage of the UN Treaty Body Review 2020 Process

August 2020

The written submission includes all the proposals developed by the Geneva Human Rights Platform since the beginning of the process. They are the outcome of a multi-year process of academic research and consultations, along with multi-stakeholder consultations.

Read more

A general view of the Human Right Council. Event

The United Nations and Human Rights: A Critical Appraisal

October 2020, 15:00-16:30

In this online event, some contributors to the new edition of Philip Alston and Frédéric Mégret’s book ‘The United Nations and Human Rights’ will examine the functions, procedures, and performance of the major UN organs dealing with human rights.

Read more

Small irrigation system with polluted water in N’Zerekore, Guinea Training

The Protection of Human Rights and the Environment

23- November 2020

This training course provides participants with a deep understanding of the international legal framework for the protection of human rights and the environment as well as in-depth knowledge of how to promote environmental protection through existing human rights mechanisms. The 2020 edition will have a specific focus on water pollution and scarcity.

Read more

Egypt, Cairo, 2011: Makeshift barricade outside interior ministry gate. Short Course

The Right to Life and the Right of Peaceful Assembly in Transitions

2- December 2020

This online short course will examine the protection afforded by international human rights law in these contexts, with a specific focus on the right to peaceful assembly – which is at the heart of such movements –, and the right to life – which is often violated during such transitional moments.

Read more

Flyer presenting the Geneva Human Rights Platform with other publications of the Geneva Academy on display Project

Geneva Academy Fridays

Started in January 2019

Read more

First annual conference of the Geneva Human Rights Platform Project

The Annual Conference of the Geneva Human Rights Platform

Started in June 2019

Read more

Cover page of the book Publication

The UN Human Rights Council: A Practical Anatomy

published on September 2020

Eric Tistounet

Read more

Cover of the publication Publication

Switzerland’s Foreign Policy and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Peasants

published on August 2020

Christophe Golay, Caroline Dommen

Read more